Thursday, May 26, 2011

Parshas Bamidbar - All for One and One for All

Thoughts on The Parsha
Parshas Bamidbar



All for One and One for All
By: Daniel Listhaus

אִישׁ עַל דִּגְלוֹ בְאֹתֹת לְבֵית אֲבֹתָם יַחֲנוּ בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל מִנֶּגֶד סָבִיב לְאֹהֶל מוֹעֵד יַחֲנוּ

The Children of Israel shall encamp, each man at his own division (by his flag) according to the signs of their fathers' house...”
-Bamidbar 2:2

The Medrash1 states that when Hashem came to Har Sinai to give the Torah to the B'nei Yisroel, twenty-two thousand chariots of malachim (angels) came down with Him - each with their own flag. When the Jews saw this they also had the desire to have their own flags. Hashem agreed that each shevet (tribe) should in fact each make for itself a flag.

What does this mean? What did the Jews see in the flags of the malachim which caused them to want to have their own? Also, what is the significance of each shevet having its own flag?

In order to answer these questions, we must first realize what a flag is. Webster translates a flag as, “any of various monocotyledonous plants with long ensiform leaves”2. However, in reality, a flag is something which brings people together.3 It symbolizes a unit. The navy, army, and air-force each have a different flag representing their own unique missions and goals. A flag is supposed to be something with which everyone in that group could identify. It is a sign to forget differences in order to achieve common goals as a unit.

At the end of Yaakov avinu's life, he called to his sons and gave each of them a b'racha (blessing). While doing so, he pointed out the unique qualities of each son, simultaneously charging each of them with a different mission in life based on their qualities.4 Immediately after this event, was the death and funeral of Yaakov. Rashi5 explains that the way the Jews surrounded the coffin of their father, Yaakov, was an allusion to the exact way that their descendents would later encamp in the desert around the Mishkan (Tabernacle), after yetzias Mitzrayim (the exodus from Egypt). Each of the twelve sons of Yaakov represents a different goal to achieve. Only when each of their individual goals is achieved, could the ultimate umbrella goal of true avodas Hashem be reached. Yaakov, as the “wholesome man, abiding in tents”6 represents this idea of what the real purpose of man is; while his twelve sons surrounding him, and later surrounding the Mishkan, represent the different entities which must form a circle to complete their overall purpose and goal.

On the third and must painful day after Avraham's circumcision, three angels disguised as men showed up at his tent. Rashi7 comments that each angel came to complete a different task. One to tell Sarah that she would give birth to a son in a year's time, one to destroy Sodom, and the third to heal Avraham. Rashi explains that the reason why three separate angels were needed was because one angel cannot perform two missions. Each angel represents a different and specific aspect of Hashem's ratzon, which is why each has their own unique flag – a symbol of what their sole purpose is.8

Just as each angel has its own mission and unique will of Hashem, each of the twelve shevatim represents a slightly different area of man serving Hashem. When the Jews in the desert saw the different flags of the angels they desired to each have their own flag so that all the members of each tribe could see and remember what the responsibilities of their tribe were. It is no coincidence that the colors of each tribe's flag were the same as their respective stones represented on the choshen (breast plate) of the Kohen Gadol9. Ruach Hakodesh assigned each of the shevatim a color, representing each shevet's unique qualities and responsibilities; and the Jews wanted each tribe to make a flag in order not to forget this

With a flag, though, comes a bigger responsibility. People united under one flag are responsible for each other. Just as soldiers in the same unit division must supplement what the other does not complete, and the whole camp is punished if the groups' tasks as a whole are not completed, so too each member of B'nei Yisroel has the responsibility to look out for a fellow Jew - “kol yisroel areivim zeh lazeh10 (every Jew is a guarantor for one another). On the smaller scale, this requires each tribe to be responsible for its members. On the larger scale, this demands each individual to be responsible for his or her fellow members of K'lal Yisroel as a whole.

As aforementioned, however, each tribe's flag is really only one-twelfth of the puzzle. The choshen is only completed when all the colors are present, Yaakov could only be buried – with passing his responsibilities of the wholesome man to his sons – once each shevet was in its rightful place alongside the coffin, and the Shechinas Hashem only travels when each shevet is surrounding it along-side its flag. Only when all twelve individual units are complete could the true ultimate big-picture be realized – that the ultimate purpose of man is to be surrounding the Mishkan, serving and coming close to Hashem. The Mishkan is the flag of flags uniting the individual units together.

When every Jews stays true to his shevet's flag, nothing evil could break the force which is created. If each shevet works to become one with its responsibilities, then a full Shechina is present - for all twelve pieces of the puzzle are in place. This was in fact the case when Bilam tried to curse the Jews.11 Balak had hired Billam to curse the Jews but when Bilam lifted his eyes to do so, he saw that the each tribe was by its respective flag. At that moment Bilam understood that his attempts to curse the Jews would be futile because he realized that the Jews had achieved the level of being by their flags – uniting each tribe within itself, and the flag of the shechina bringing the twelve parts into one whole.12

We must realize that everything is really one. Hashem is one, His name is one, and His nation is one. These factors are not meant to be added together, for they are in reality all one and the same. Hashem's name is one and Jews are called “goy echad b'aretz” (one nation in the land). When these two echads intersect at the right point then the ultimate oneness is present. This is alluded to through the gematriya (numerical values of the Hebrew letters) one calculates when adding together these two “echads”. The gematriya of echad is thirteen plus another echad equals twenty-six13 which is the gematriya of the explicit name of Hashem.14

This idea of connecting the achdus (unity) of the Jews with Hashem is further displayed by the Tefillin we wear. Tefillin is the wireless network, so to speak, connecting us directly with Hashem. When we wear Tefillin, we show that we are tied, literally, with Hashem. For this reason, our Tefillin has the Shema written in it, declaring, “Hashem echad” - that G-d is One. On Hashem's side of the connection, the Gemara15 tells us that Hashem also wears a pair of Tefillin and on it its written: “Who is like your nation Israel, one nation in the land”. This is why the Gemara16 states that whoever recites shema without tefillin is as if he bears false testimony on himself.

Judaism is not merely a religion, it is a way of life. Each of us has the duty to balance our individual responsibilities while remembering that we also belong to a bigger picture. It is true that each shevet has its own responsibility it must work towards, however, there is yet a bigger picture. Each shevet's flag shares a common denominator, that all of their flags have a collective flag - the shechina - located exactly in the center of all four camps.

Every individual must look up at one's tribe's flag and recall one's mission. Then, each tribe as a unit must produce its complete gem, as represented on the choshen, in order to conjointly achieve the ultimate goal: true service of Hashem through building the relationship of oneness between He, who is One, and His nation, who is one – two sides of the same coin.

Being in galus (exile), we have lost touch with the small picture responsibilities of each tribe. However, let us not forget the bigger picture, the ultimate goal of the entire Jewish people to be close with the shechina. This is what we hope for in the future by the times of Mashiach; the day we describe three times daily at the end of Aleinu L'shabeach17 as, “On that day shall Hashem be One and His name be One”.

1Tanchuma Bamidbar 14
2Webster's Dictionary :“flag”. (Don't worry, Webster is not totally off his rocker, under the flag entry there is also: “a usually rectangular piece of fabric of distinctive design that is used as a symbol”.)
3Rashi Yeshaya 5:26
4 See Beraishis 49:1-28
5Beraishis 50:13
6Beraishis 25:27 Rashi there explains that Yaakov would spend his time in the tents of Shem and Eiver studying Torah.
7Beraishis 18:2
8See Rashbam 2:2 and other commentaries who describe what was on each shevet's flag. For example: On the flag of Yehuda was a lion; and on the flag of Yosef was an ox.
9Medrash Tanchuma 12-14; Rabbeinu BeChayei
10 Rashi Vayikra 26:37 and Sanhedrin 27b. Note: The word “areiv” literally means a guarantor. Just like by monetary law a guarantor is forced to pay in place of the original debtor (if the debtor is unable to pay and other conditions are met), so too every Jew is in some way responsible for what another Jew does or does not do.
11Bamidbar 24:2
12Medrash Tanchuma 14
13Alef=1 + Ches=8 + Daled=4 for a total of 13 times 2 = Grand total of 26
14The four-letter name of Hashem ; Yud=10 + Hey=5 + Vav=6 +Hey=5 for a total of 26
15Brachos 6a
16Brachos 14b

17Said at the end of Shacharis, Mincha, and Ma'ariv – from Zechariyah 14:9

Photo Credit: Edited picture based on http://www.thefoundationstone.org/images/stories/israel.jpg

Thursday, May 19, 2011

Parshas Bechukosai

 Recognizing Real Reward
By: Daniel Listhaus

“If you will go in My decrees and observe My commandments and perform them; then I will provide your rains in their time, and the land will give its produce and the tree of the field will give its fruit….I will walk among you….”
-Bechukosai 26:3-4;12

All of the blessings which are described at the beginning of this week’s Parsha are rewarded to us as a whole when we follow in the way of Hashem[1]. As Chizkuni[2] writes, “If you do what I (Hashem) put on you, then the land which was created for you will put forth most productively”. The extent of these blessings is indeed great. As a matter of fact, the Medrash[3]  points out that the brachos cover everything from Alef to Taf, representing the bountiful amount of goodness coming to the one who follows in Hashem’s ways[4].

When reading these opening verses in the Parsha, however, two questions immediately come to mind. First of all, the Mussar books[5] teach us that there are many levels on which one can perform mitzvos. Doing mitzvos for the sake of receiving reward does not occupy the highest of these ranks. As a matter of fact, we know this from Pirkei Avos[6], which suggests that when doing the mitzvos of Hashem we should not be like servants who work for their master on the condition of receiving a reward, but rather like [the more devoted] servants who serve their master even without demanding reward. If this is indeed the case, then why is it that when discussing the ones who keep Hashem’s commandments, the Torah finds it necessary to describe their rewards?

 Additionally, as sort of a follow up question, once the Torah did in fact decide to illustrate the rewards of those who follow the right path, why discuss the blessings which man has the potential to enjoy on Earth? That is only the minor leagues. We know that the real purpose of living cannot solely be for life as we know it because as Dovid HaMelech writes in Tehillim[7], “The days of our years are seventy and eighty if with strength; their proudest success is but toil and pain – for it is cut off short and we fly away”. Koheles[8] too, written by Shlomo HaMelech, is devoted to speaking of the futility of this world. So, rather, the purpose of living in this world must be something much greater - to perfect our Neshamos (souls) and do as many mitzvos as we can so that when we reach Olam Habbah (the World to Come) we could receive our true reward. So why is it that the Torah chose to describe the limited blessings and rewards that this world has to offer if in fact there is a whole major leagues waiting in Olam Habbah for those who followed in Hashem’s ways by observing His mitzvos?

The Kli Yakar[9] is bothered mainly by our second question. In response, he compiles seven different answers as to why the Torah does not mention the rewards of Olam Habbah. The first answer he brings down is the Rambam’s opinion. The Rambam[10] writes that of course Olam Habbah is the ultimate reward - and that is indeed a basic assumption throughout the Torah. All that the Torah is coming to teach here is that if one chooses the correct path, then Hashem will help us with the rest, making it easier for us to serve Him by removing the determents. The Kli Yakar then brings down six other answers[11], most of which are more along the lines of either that people cannot grasp what the reward of Olam Habbah truly is, or based on that the Torah was coming to counter the various beliefs and assumptions existing during the era around when the Torah was given on Har Sinai.  

 Two of these answers that the Kli Yakar brings down are from the Kuzari[12]. And although the Kli Yakar lists them as two separate answers, which they are, they really stem from the same foundation as could be seen when analyzing the Kuzari’s discussion with the Chaver (who will be referred to here as “Rabbi”).

Amongst a discussion between the Kuzari and the Rabbi, the Kuzari[13] mentions that he is perplexed due to the following two facts which do not seem to add up correctly. On the one hand, other religions seem to offer better rewards in the world to come than is offered in Judaism. However, at the same time, if one would ask them if they would want to die early to receive their great reward, they would all turn down the offer immediately and would rather push off their great rewards one-thousand years to live here on Earth longer.

The Rabbi responded the Kuzari in the following way. First of all, in other religions all their rewards purportedly come to fruition only after death and that there is neither benefit in this life nor any indication in this life of the promised future reward. However in Judaism we are not merely promised an afterlife of nice fields and other things as promised by other religions. Rather, the ultimate reward is closeness to Hashem. And there is indication of such a reward in this world. One can achieve, to some extent, closeness to Hashem during one’s lifetime and could actually experience extreme closeness to Hashem via nevuah (prophecy). The Rabbi continued to point out that such a person who got a taste of such closeness in this world does not fear death, unlike people of other religions, because he only wants to be close to Hashem. The Rabbi then proceeds to explain that this is the reason why the rewards of Olam Habbah are not mentioned in the Torah. He explains that the Torah just tells us that we will be a nation to Hashem and that He will be a G-d for us and lead us. Hashem promises that if we keep to His commandments, then we will experience living in Eretz Yisroel (Israel) in a manner most conducive to being able to achieve such a spiritual level. This is because the operations of this world do not really have a default “nature” setting as it seems, but rather works depending on our actions. If we follow in the ways of Hashem then the land will, accordingly, produce its full potential. However, if we chas v'shalom (G-d forbid) do not follow the ways of Hashem, then the world will also act accordingly and bring forth famine, plague, and wild animals until we realize that we are not merely guided by the laws of nature, but rather something greater - Hashem. Someone who achieves this level of realization will not fear death because he realizes the goodness which awaits him. This is how the Torah demonstrates the rewards which await us after death - through the spiritual rewards of closeness that exist in this world.

The Rabbi seems to be explaining in our Parsha that it is our duty to realize that our actions in this world have a direct relationship with the way that the world acts back. There is a pure positive correlation: When “Im Bechukosai Teileichu….” (If you will go in My decrees…) then “V'nasati gishmeichem ba’aretz” (…then I will provide your rains). And, unfortunately, the opposite is true as well that if we do not keep the ways of Hashem then the land will not “cooperate” as we may like. However, it is not on this surface level of following in Hashem’s ways in order to receive these blessings which is the ultimate achievement, but rather quite deeper- it is the closeness to Hashem which we could achieve through realizing that Hashem controls every aspect of the world.

Now we could perhaps better understand what the beginning of this week's Parsha is accomplishing. To answer our first question, it is not that the Torah is specifically coming to teach the rewards of the one who follows in the way of Hashem, but rather is taking it to the next step and describing that in reality the ultimate purpose of doing the mitzvos is for this high level of L’shma - for the sole sake of reaching a closer d’veikus BaHashem (relationship with Hashem) to the point where we can attain “…v’hishalachti b’sochichem…. – (I [Hashem] will walk among you). And it is not that the Torah chose the lesser of the two types of rewards by describing the finite rewards of this world. Rather, the Torah is describing the highest achievement of reward, which is in fact infinite and does provide a pure taste of the world to come. This is the coming to the realization that Hashem is behind everything. In other words it isn't the rain or good crop which is the reward but rather the seeing that because of what we do we could receive such blessings because of our relationship with Hashem. Exactly as the Rabbi told the Kuzari, “This is how the Torah demonstrates the rewards which await us after death - through the spiritual rewards of closeness that exist in this world”.

May we all achieve the level where we can truly feel and honestly realize what we say multiple times a day in Modim[14], “We gratefully thank You... For our lives, which are committed to your power and for our souls that are entrusted to you; for Your miracles that are with us every day; and for your wonders and favors on every season - evening, morning, and afternoon...." [15]







[1] Rashi (Vayikra 26:3), amongst other Rishonim learn that when the Passuk says “If you will go in My decrees” it refers specifically to Ameilus BaTorah (laboring in Torah study).
[2] Vayikra 26:3
[3] Vayikra Rabbah 35:1
[4] The Eitz Yosef there on the Medrash explains that the first letter of the blessings in this Parsha is in fact an “Alef” (Im Bechukosai) and that it in fact ends with the letter “Taf” (Kom’im’miyus)
[5] For example, Sha’arei Ohr Chapter 1
[6] Pirkei Avos 1:3
[7] Tehillim 90:10 We also recite this in Pesukei D’zimra on Shabbos at Shacharis
[8] The theme for Koheles is, as the second Passuk states, “Vanity of vanities, said Koheles; vanity of vanities all is vanity.”
[9] Vayikra 26:12
[10] Hilchos Teshuva 9:1
[11] Including Ra'vaah in Haazinu 32:39, Rabeinu B'chaye, and Rambam in Moreh Nevuchim Chapter 3
[12] Written by Rabbi Yehuda HaLevi
[13] Kuzari 1:104-109
[14] Part of every shemoneh esreh
[15] Translation taken from Artscroll-Mesorah siddur

Monday, May 16, 2011

Parshas Behar - A Test of Trust


Thoughts on The Parsha
Parshas Behar



A Test of Trust
By: Daniel Listhaus

שֵׁשׁ שָׁנִים תִּזְרַע שָׂדֶךָ וְשֵׁשׁ שָׁנִים תִּזְמֹר כַּרְמֶךָ וְאָסַפְתָּ אֶת תְּבוּאָתָהּ: וּבַשָּׁנָה הַשְּׁבִיעִת שַׁבַּת שַׁבָּתוֹן יִהְיֶה לָאָרֶץ שַׁבָּת לַיהֹוָה שָׂדְךָ לֹא תִזְרָע וְכַרְמְךָ לֹא תִזְמֹר

For six years you may sow your field and for six years you may prune your vineyard, and you may gather in its crop. But on the seventh year there shall be a complete rest for the land, a Shabbos for Hashem; your field you shall not plow and your vineyard you shall not prune.”

-Behar 25:3-4

            The laws of shemittah are many and are hard to keep. However, as hard as it is to keep the laws of shemittah, it is exponentially harder to comprehend them. If one would tell a farmer that every seventh year he must leave his land fallow and not only refrain from working it, but that he is also prohibited to derive benefit from selling its produce, the farmer would look at this person and either think you he or she is crazy or would laugh, saying that a person who says such nonsense has a naive understanding of farming. A field cannot just be laid fallow for a year doing no work on it. Not only is it bad for the field, but even more so, how is a farmer supposed to make money if he is giving away his produce for free? Yet, Hashem commands us to do this in Eretz Yisrael every seventh year. As a matter of fact, Hashem not only promises that we will not lose in the process, but even promises that we will have plenty of food and profit to live off of for the seventh and eighth[1] year[2]. 

            The Gemara in Kiddushin[3] and Rashi[4] at the end of the Parsha state that even the lighter prohibitions of shemittah must be taken with an extreme seriousness. Both the Gemara and Rashi proceed to point out that the juxtaposition of all the topics contained in Parshas Behar is not accidental, but rather coming to teach what happens to the one who transgresses on even a minor prohibition of shemittah. One who as so much becomes suspect with regard to shemittah and goes ahead and sells his fruits to ensure and feel secure that he will have cash in his wallet, will find himself needing to sell his possessions. If at that point he does not do Teshuva, he will find himself needing to also sell his ancestral heritage. If he still refuses to repent, he will reach a state of poverty in which he will be forced to sell his house. If he continues his stubbornness he will be in such a bad financial position and need to borrow money on interest[5]. If he has not yet learned his lesson he will come to having no alternative but to sell himself as a slave to a Jew. If even this is not enough to awaken him, he will come to being sold to a non-Jew.
            Additionally, the Gemara Sanhedrin[6], as well as Rashi in our Parsha[7], and Rashi in Parshas Bechukosai[8] describe that the reason we went into Galus Bavel (the Babylonian exile) for seventy years is because we did not keep the laws of shemittah[9].

            What is so important about keeping the laws of shemittah which calls for such severe punishment on Earth, even for merely transgressing its most minor prohibitions?

            The Gemara in Sanhedrin[10] asks, “Why did Hashem command the B'nei Yisroel (Jews) to keep the laws of shemittah? In order that they should know that the land is mine.” The Kli Yakar[11] and Cheshek Shlomo[12] explain further. They write that the reason for the mitzva of shemittah is to work on one's Emunah and Bitachon in Hashem. Hashem was concerned, so to speak, that after entering the land of Israel and working the land through Minhagei HaTivi (normal means of working a field), we will get so into the routine of planting, working the field, and gathering the crops that we will come to forget that it is in fact Hashem who is hiding among the works of “nature”; instead, we may start to consider that it is through our hard work and accomplishments which created our own crops thereby providing us with wealth. Therefore, every seventh year Hashem takes us completely out of Minhagei HaTivi and commands us to leave the land to rest. By us keeping the laws of shemittah and refraining from working our fields despite having nothing tangible in our wallets other then the IOU guarantee from Hashem that every sixth year will produce enough for three years, we achieve the highest form of faith and trust in Hashem. We are forced into the realization of Hashem Echad (is One). That everything in this world is dependent on Hashem, though He is dependent on nothing.

            This is why the one who transgresses on even a minor aspect of shemittah is punished so harshly. The one who sells the fruits of shevi'is is exhibiting a lack of faith and trust in Hashem and is punished measure-for-measure. He must be shown that despite the fact that he went ahead and tried to secure money, he will ultimately find himself selling himself as a slave; while his friends, who kept the shemittah and learned the lesson to constantly remember that Hashem is the one running the world, albeit behind his mask called nature, enjoy their abundance of food and wealth. And if happens that the nation as a general whole will begin to disregard the shemittah with the belief that it is through our own hard work and effort which provides for us, we must then go into exile to realize that we are nothing without Hashem and that the land belongs to Him.

            The Orchos Tzaddikim[13] (Ways of the Righteous) a book on ethics devoted to perfecting one's characteristic traits, writes that the opposite of worry is joy. He explains that true simcha (Joy/Happiness) is specifically measured on how much faith one has in Hashem. A person with no faith could have all the money in the world and not be happy, whereas the one who has faith and trust in Hashem could have little but be the happiest person on Earth.
           
            With this in mind, let us revisit the one who disregards the shemittah year. The reason one would be hesitant to adhere to laws of shemittah is because of a nervousness that it is impossible to accumulate wealth while one's field remains fallow. This person is worried because he lacks the faith in Hashem. The one who is happy, however, meaning that his Emunah and Bitachon are an essential part of him, remains happy as he knows that there is a Master of the world Who does not merely watch as an outsider, but actually involves himself in a Hashgacha P'ratis way – taking care of the needs of each individual. This is why the Orchos Tzaddikim writes that the trait of worry and joy are exact opposites of each other.

            The lesson we could take out of the importance of the mitzva of shemittah is to remember that Hashem is the One who is truly behind all the workings of this world, even the things which we sometimes feel we maintain full control over. We must keep in mind that just as an employee recognizes that it is not the mailman who writes his check, but rather his boss using the mailman as a means of delivery, so too we must realize that Hashem is the source of all, hiding behind a mask, and chooses to deliver our needs to us through means of His messengers. This is why Hashem gives us this test of trust every seven years.
             


[1]    The eighth year is really the first year, because the shemittah cycle is a seven-year cycle. However, for simplicity's sake the Torah refers to it as the eighth year. The exception to this is the Yovel year which is every fiftieth year (after seven shemittah cycles) of the Yovel cycle.
[2]    Vayikra 25:21-22 These verses promise that the sixth year will yield enough crop for three years (i.e- years 6, 7, and 8). This is one of many places in the Torah where it is so clear that the Torah was written by Hashem and not man, for how could man promise and guarantee such a miraculous thing that every seven years he will provide all those keeping the laws of shemittah with three years worth of crops?
[3]    Kiddushin 20a
[4]    Vayikra 26:1
[5]    At this point, Rashi interjects and writes, “All these latter ones are harsher than the previous ones”. The Nachalas Yaakov explains that the reason Rashi writes this at this particular point is to counter the thought one may have that borrowing with interest is not as bad as having to sell your house, ancestral heritage, or possessions. The reason Rashi counters this thought is because one can redeem one's house, ancestral heritage, or possessions, but when paying interest on borrowed money, that money is lost forever.
[6]    Sanhedrin 39a
[7]    Rashi, Vayikra 25:18
[8]    Rashi, Vayikra 26:35
[9]    Rashi in Vayikra 26:35 makes the calculation of when the seventy years were, during which the Jews did not keep the laws of shemittah.
[10]  Sanhedrin 39a
[11]  Vayikra 22:1
[12]  Cheshek Shlomo Kiddushin 20a
[13]  Orchos Tzaddikim: Sha'ar HaSimcha (Orchos Tzaddikim: The Ninth Gate; The Gate of Happiness)
Photo Credit: earthsky.org/human-world/dawn-of-agriculture-took-toll-on-health